The State of Search in the Wake of Google’s Antitrust Trial Loss
What's Going On?
On August 5th, 2024, Judge Amit Mehta issued a ruling in the case of US v. Google. This was the biggest tech antitrust trial since the US v. Microsoft case back in the 1990’s, and without a doubt has resulted in the most significant outcome since, as the ruling concluded with Google on the losing end. In the ruling, Judge Mehta declared that Google “is a monopolist, and had violated Section 2 of the Sherman Act.” So, what happens next?
First, let’s look at the history. The case was three years in the making, and involved a whole plethora of allegations which then led to intensive competitive research, countless interviews and interrogations, as well as some high-profile testimony. As a result of the verdict, the Justice Department and State Attorneys General are said to be considering a wide range of remedies including but not limited to a breakup of the company. However, we do not want to sound too alarmist, and the case may indeed be appealed as far up as the U.S. Supreme Court. Nonetheless, all marketers as well as business owners, and that is just to name a few, need to be well aware of what is going on here, and if you are not staying abreast of the evolving developments, you are falling behind. You should start developing mitigation strategies that take into account worst case scenarios. And if the actions taken do end up not being as impactful as they can be, you will still have improved your online presence in ways that will likely be profitable and long-lasting. Said simply, you stand to lose more than you stand to gain, but an attitude of indifference will likely lead to losses for you, your clients, or both. Not only that, there is another case coming up in September addressing Google’s alleged tactics in establishing overall digital advertising dominance.
There are many moving parts here, and action will be required.
What Is the Google Antitrust Trial?
The Google antitrust trial is a significant legal battle that has captured widespread attention, extending beyond the tech industry.
Launched by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) in 2020, this trial examined whether Google has used anti-competitive practices to maintain its market dominance. Central to the case are Google’s agreements with companies like Apple, where it allegedly paid billions to secure its position as the default search engine, potentially suppressing competition and innovation.
Google, however, disputes these claims, arguing that users choose Google simply because it’s the superior search engine. The trial began in 2023 and featured testimony from prominent figures such as Google CEO Sundar Pichai and Microsoft’s Satya Nadella.
Closing arguments were concluded in May, and by August, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta ruled against Google. The company is likely to appeal, and the case could eventually reach the Supreme Court. Another federal antitrust case, this one focusing on Google’s dominance in digital advertising, is scheduled to start in September.
For digital marketers, the outcome of this trial is crucial. It has the potential to drastically alter SEO playbooks and pay-per-click (PPC) strategies, possibly even reshaping our entire approach to online visibility.
So, keep coming back to learn more as things may be changing at a rapid pace as this all runs its course.
Why Did the Google Antitrust Trial Happen?
Why has Google been brought to court? It’s all about competition—or the lack thereof, according to the Justice Department. Google controls approximately 90 percent of the U.S. search market, a massive share that has sparked significant concerns.
The government alleges that Google’s agreements, particularly those where it pays large sums to secure top spots on devices and browsers, are more about stifling competition than improving user experience.
This trial is a pivotal moment in determining whether Google’s size and practices are too restrictive, making it difficult for smaller companies to compete. The broader issue is whether existing antitrust laws can effectively regulate tech giants and ensure a fair digital marketplace.
The accusations include:
Direct Deals
- Anticompetitive Practices: Allegations of Google paying billions to secure default search engine status on devices and browsers, with $26.3 billion spent in 2021 alone.
Shutting Out Competitors
- Market Dominance: Smaller search engines, like DuckDuckGo, claim Google’s strategies create barriers to entry and hinder their growth.
Hindering Innovation
- Innovation Stifled: Critics argue that Google’s market dominance discourages the development of new search technologies and ideas.
Impact on Advertisers
- Advertising Monopoly: Google’s control over the search market could lead to higher advertising costs and reduced competition for advertisers.
Google’s defense? The company insists that people choose their search engine because of the quality it offers. Google also argues that changing your default search engine is straightforward, so if users wanted alternatives, they would switch.
The outcome of the Google antitrust trial could change how we view search engines and create opportunities for alternative search engines to gain prominence. For marketers, this may require a reevaluation of digital strategies.
A Timeline of Developments and Outcomes
The Google antitrust trial has been a high-stakes event with far-reaching implications for the tech industry.
Here’s a summary of the major developments and their potential impact on Google and the broader tech landscape:
- Start of the Trial: The Google antitrust trial kicked off on September 12, 2023, with the DOJ alleging that Google abused its market power to maintain dominance in search.
- Google Antitrust Trial Dates:
- – September 12, 2023: Trial begins.
- – October 30, 2023: Disclosure of Google’s payments to Apple.
- – November 16, 2023: Trial phase concludes.
- – May 3, 2024: Closing arguments end.
- – August 5, 2024: Judge Amit Mehta rules against Google.
- – September 2024: A separate federal trial focused on Google’s digital advertising dominance, presided over by U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema, is set to begin.
- Google Antitrust Trial Dates:
- High-Profile Testimony: Industry titans like Google CEO Sundar Pichai and Microsoft’s Satya Nadella took the stand, offering contrasting perspectives on the competitive landscape of the search market.
- Financial Revelations: The trial revealed the extent of Google’s financial commitment to maintaining its default search engine status on Apple devices, with Google paying Apple a staggering $18 billion in 2021 alone.
- Allegations of Antitrust: The DOJ presented evidence suggesting that Google’s actions may have stifled competition and harmed consumers by prioritizing its own products and services.
- Google’s Defense: Google defended its practices, arguing that its search engine’s quality and business model are legitimate and that consumers have ample choice in the marketplace.
- Judge’s Ruling: Judge Mehta’s ruling declared Google an illegal monopoly, potentially leading to significant fines, regulatory changes, or even restructuring of Google’s business partnerships.
- Industry and Public Impact: Regardless of the outcome, the trial has ignited debates about data privacy, market fairness, and the future of digital advertising.
Implications for Marketing Professionals
Marketers should be prepared for potential changes:
SEO Shake-Up
- If Google’s algorithms are forced to change, your existing SEO strategies might require a complete overhaul. This could lead to a shift in how Google ranks pages, with an even greater emphasis on factors like E-E-A-T (experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness). Also, it can never hurt to focus on Search Generative Experience (SGE). As the chart below shows, search is no longer synonymous with Google, a realization that had come to pass long before this ruling.
Ad Game Changes
- Google’s advertising policies might face tighter regulations, leading to changes in audience targeting and campaign optimization. Be ready to adapt your PPC strategies rapidly.
Data Dilemmas
- New restrictions on data usage could emerge, affecting how user behavior is tracked and how personalized marketing efforts are crafted.
Increased Competition
- If the trial results in a more competitive search market, you might need to optimize for multiple search engines, not just Google.
Content Still Rules
- With potential algorithm adjustments, high-quality, authoritative content that demonstrates E-E-A-T will remain crucial as a guiding set of principles here.
Chart showing the percentage of consumers who begin a product or solution search across various channels.
What It Means for Your Business
As a business owner or marketing professional, the Google antitrust trial could have direct implications for your digital marketing approach. Media buyers are already weighing all of their options. Here’s some practical advice to stay ahead:
- Diversify Your Digital Presence: Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. As the search landscape evolves, consider expanding your reach to include Bing, DuckDuckGo, and social media platforms. Incorporate these additional search engines into your SEO strategy to future-proof your online presence.
- Prioritize User Experience: A positive user experience remains a cornerstone of successful digital marketing. Optimize your website for speed, mobile compatibility, and easy navigation, regardless of search engine dominance.
- Build Off-Platform Relationships: Strengthen your direct connection with customers through email marketing, community building, and content marketing on your own platforms. This will help you maintain a loyal customer base even if search engine algorithms change.
- Stay Informed: Keep tabs on the Google antitrust trial by setting up Google Alerts and following reputable tech news sources. Understanding the latest developments will help you anticipate potential changes in the digital landscape.
- Invest in Data Analytics: As data privacy regulations may tighten, having robust data collection and analysis capabilities will be crucial. Utilize data-driven insights to inform your marketing strategies and measure performance.
- Double Down on E-E-A-T: Emphasize the quality and authority of your content to demonstrate expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness. These factors will likely remain important, even if search engine algorithms evolve.
- Be Agile: The digital landscape is constantly changing. Be prepared to adapt your marketing strategies quickly to address new challenges and opportunities arising from the Google antitrust trial.
Remember, change brings opportunity. By staying informed and adaptable, you can turn these potential challenges into advantages for your business. Keep delivering value to your customers, and you’ll be well-positioned no matter what happens.
Conclusions
As noted above, and alluding to the Microsoft Antitrust case back in the 1990’s, there are a million different scenarios that can unfold here. In the least case scenario, Google’s practices will be restrained and they will be hit with significant fines. Even if they stopped allocating huge sums of money to the likes of Apple, at this point many consumers would choose Google as their default search engine even if it was not set as the default search engine out of the box.The worst case scenario could result in a breakup of the company as we know it, which would obviously mark a turning point for the entire digital marketing industry.
It is wise to start thinking about diversification now. As noted above, search is no longer synonymous with Google. Marketing principles are Google agnostic and should be applied here. Keep representing yourself or your clients (as the case may be) by providing value in the form of quality. Experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness. Embrace NOW the omnichannel approach. You need to keep a close eye on this, but remember that in the past four years, federal antitrust regulators have also sued Meta Platforms (META.O), Amazon.com (AMZN.O), and Apple (AAPL.O), claiming the companies have illegally maintained monopolies. Antitrust enforcement cases always seem to garner strong bipartisan support. They are not going away. Do NOT get caught in the trap of paralysis by analysis. Push the pedal further down on your marketing efforts.
In closing, some may not recall what was the largest tech antitrust case of them all, that being U.S. vs. IBM. This actually ran from 1969 to 1982! In his article titled ‘The Ghosts of Antitrust Past’, Alec Stapp states “The case lasted so long, and expanded in scope so much, that by the time the trial began, “more than half of the practices the government raised as antitrust violations were related to products that did not exist in 1969.” Baltimore law professor Robert Lande said it was “the largest legal case of any kind ever filed.” Yale law professor Robert Bork called it “the antitrust division’s Vietnam.”
What IBM did over the course of the trial was to raise their prices so much that, within the span of the trial, their market share fell from about 50% down to just 37%. They did this to intentionally lose market share so as to weaken the government’s case and thus remain status quo as far as the structure of the company.
With a 90% market share, Google had no way to dodge the outcome here (as IBM did) in light of the allegations which – quite honestly, most would say simply represent sound business practices. I know that most marketers love Google, and certainly their shareholders love their strategic approach to the market and maintaining/extending their position through aggressive expansion beyond just search. At this point, Google offers over 200 products overall.
Trust in the principle of staying in the moment, while also being ready for a worst-case scenario which can ultimately be converted into a wonderful opportunity for growth if pre-emptive strategies are put into place, now.
Contact Us to learn more!
